So, I'm a little late to the party, but I did see the first showing out in LA with the rest of our KOTOR movie team (we all loved it, btw). In case for some unknown reason you still haven't seen the film, I'm not going to get into spoiler territory about all the plot points I liked or didn't like, especially since they've been covered already, so I'll just add some observations I've made from other comments in this thread..
First off, some of you are complaining that TFA was too much like ANH and didn't like the fact that it wasn't more original. Then, the same people complain that TLJ was TOO original and subverted expectations in too many ways. I've seen the same arguments on other media platforms too. You can't have it both ways, guys.
I've read comments about R1 being a better movie, which is debatable. R1 and TLJ are two very different movies, with R1 having the advantage of you already knowing what's going to happen. At least with TLJ you have some characters with personality... the R1 cast was forgettable (even the lead), which makes it nearly impossible to connect with them or even care about their deaths. Still, R1 was a fine movie because of the action and getting to see how an important event you know from SW canon actually played out. There were some cool moments, even the unneeded Vader fan service at the end, but overall the movie definitely was not 'awesome'. I'd rank it only in front of the prequels. Speaking of prequels....
...there's this crazy talk about the prequels being better than TLJ. Sure, you're entitled to your own opinions, but come on guys....prequels better than TLJ?! That's almost 'Turn in your SW Fan Card' territory right there. Those of you that liked the prequels better must have only liked the Canto Bight scenes in the movie then, which were some of the worst in the film.
I've seen a lot of negativity about the humor in the film too. The opening Poe dialogue pretty much sets the tone for humor in this movie, so if you didn't like that, it's no surprise you didn't like the rest. Sure, not all the jokes landed, but overall I thought the humor was justified because it either matched what the character would do (e.g. Poe as he was in TFA) or the situation (e.g. Luke and the saber). Don't tell me the humor is too slapstick or inappropriate in TLJ, but that you also enjoyed the prequels, which were beyond silly at times.
And yes, there seemed to be some universally despised moments in the film, but no way was there enough of these moments to pull down the overall movie. I feel like there's so many nitpickers on here wanting to make their own 'Everything Wrong With...' videos instead of just enjoying the film. The other problem is that it seems too many of you are making your minds up about the trilogy after seeing only two movies. Maybe some of the choices you didn't like in TLJ will make more sense once you see Ep 9. It's too early IMO to judge this movie without having the full trilogy available for context. Don't forget there were plenty of disappointed fans after ESB too who weren't happy about the departure from ANH, and things turned out pretty well after ROTJ, which ppl to seemed to like more initially than ESB, but is considered the weakest of the OT now by most fans. I predict TLJ will bring the doubting fans around after Ep 9, much like ROTJ did after ESB. Doubters definitely need to see this whole trilogy play out before they classify TLJ as a bad movie.
I'm also not convinced that some of the big reveals/shocking moments will hold up. It's clear RJ and Disney wanted to subvert expectations so much that I wouldn't be surprised if there were more misdirects made than we realized, which would lead to more unexpected moments in Ep 9. I, for one, am excited about Ep 9 because I have no idea what's going to happen or what the movie is even going to be about. Sort of like ESB, you weren't sure where the story was going to go after the Vader as Luke's father reveal, but at least you had that conflict out there, a frozen Han, and an evil emperor....with Ep 9, you know very little so anything could happen.
TLJ isn't perfect by any means. Some jokes fell flat, the story felt bloated at times with silly plot points, and there was at least one really stupid thing that happened, but overall I had fun at both viewings...I actually enjoyed it more the second time around. I'll be anxiously awaiting 2019, and as a true SW fan, I'll be seeing Ep 9 opening night in theaters. Feel free to wait until it comes out on Netflix....less grumbling and sighing around me then as I'm trying to enjoy the movie.